Skip to main content

Squash! Identity in Swallowtail Butterfly


Good Morning Blog,


One of the first things I noticed in this movie was the collection roles of identities presented. For example, take Glico.Glico was born in China, so part of her identity is Chinese. She now lives in Japan, so another part of her identity is Japanese. And finally, she lives in Yentown, which has its own identity as Yentown. Many other characters in the movie also share this “Third” identity. 

Even though Glico has three cultural identities, she really only identifies with two: Chinese and Yentown. Interestly, Yentown, though it is in Japan, is not considered Japanese by the Japanese natives due to its overwhelming large population of foreigners. Identity is something that is fluid, but the Japanese here have created borders on what it means to be “Japanese.” This is the same thing with one of the other characters in the movie, the man who proposed the idea of “Third Culture.” The man has American parents yet he was born in Japan. He has grown up living in Japan and knowing Japanese culture, however, due to his appearance he is always treated as a foreigner. Even though he is as culturally and nationally Japanese as someone who is racially Japanese, he gets treated as an outcast.
I think this movie brings good topics on what it means to be Japanese. Are you defined by your racial heritage, cultural heritage, what language you speak, or where do you live? The stereotype is that Japan is homogeneous in culture and ethnicities, but that is far from the truth. This movie is a perfect example of how multicultural and multiethnic Japan really is. There are so many languages being spoken here and there are so many different cultures represented alongside Japan.

Bye for now,


Works Cited: Swallowtail Butterfly

Comments

  1. Margot SobotaMay 10, 2020 at 12:45 PM

    This scene left an impact on me as well. It really highlights the second generation immigrants who have ties to their birth country as well as some ties to the homeland of their parents. Yet, if they do not visually pass as the dominant ethnicity, they unfortunately forever get treated as foreigners. It is a very sad, but accurate reality for many.

    ReplyDelete
  2. MaggieMay 10, 2020 at 3:49 PM

    Hey Allison,

    I like the questions you pose at the end about how multicultural Japan really is. I think the scene you mentioned about the "American" man really answers the question. Although he is culturally and nationally Japanese, he is still outcasted because of his American appearance. This implies that even though Japan is filled with many immigrants and people of different cultures and races, those groups are still outcasted and viewed as the minority group, unaccepted into what is defined as "true Japanese culture". I think it exposes that although Japan prides itself in being a multiethnic society, it is still very monolithic in values and views.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Fred FengMay 10, 2020 at 9:08 PM

    Great connections you made from the movie to existing stigma in the Japanese society. Japan definitely is a bit more traditional than western countries when it comes to acceptance and identity with foreigners. The analysis you provided from the movie is easy to understand and see.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Healing With Cooking

Healing With Cooking Good Morning Blog, I have just finished reading Kitchen, and I absolutely loved it. I really enjoyed the “sweetness” in her writing, or as Ann Sherif says, “[Banana Yoshimoto] handles serious subjects with a remarkably light hand or even, as many critics have noted, a studied nonchalance.” (279). Also, there was something about the symbolism of the kitchen and food that made me really love this novel, too. Before reading this novel, I didn’t realize the significance of meals in this novel; this element helped to play a large role in the healing of the characters. To begin, when Mikage stays over the summer with Yuichi and Eriko, she gathers everyone together with her home-cooked meals. Even when everyone has such differentiating schedules and they hardly get the chance to see each other, “[I]t was because of my cooking that the three of us ate together as often as we did…” (57) This is the time that all three of them can come together, bond, and eat like...
1 comment
Read more

Moment-to-Moment With Tobio's Death

Good Evening Blog,  Before taking this class, I’ve never really gotten the chance to critically think and analyze comics and manga before. When I've read comics and manga in the past, I really just paid attention to the story and the pretty art. But, after reading Scott McCloud’s Understanding Comics, I’ve come to realize that like all other art forms, there are deeper reasons why a comic artist chooses to draw in a certain style and how they choose to present their ideas.  This is especially true in Tezuka Osamu’s Astro Boy. The way that Osamu has chosen to use specific techniques in his panel-to-panel has helped to bring out crucial points in his manga. In McCloud’s book, he names 6 different types of paneling that are used in comics and manga: moment-to-moment, action-to-action, subject-to-subject, scene-to-scene, aspect-to-aspect, and non-sequitur. I feel that one of the best scenes in Astro Boy is Tobio’s death. Not because Tobio died, but because the way that ...
1 comment
Read more